History of radiation therapy
The history of radiation therapy or radiotherapy can be traced back to experiments made soon after the discovery of x-rays (1895), when it was shown that exposure to radiation produced cutaneous burns. Influenced by electrotherapy and escharotics — the medical application of caustic substances — doctors began using radiation to treat growths and lesions produced by diseases such as lupus, rodent ulcer, and epithelioma. Radiation was generally believed to have bactericidal properties, so when radium was discovered, in addition to treatments similar to those used with x-rays, it was also used as an additive to medical treatments for diseases such as tuberculosis where there were resistant bacilli.
Additionally, because radiation was found to exist in hot spring waters which were reputed for their curative powers, it was marketed as a wonder cure for all sorts of ailments in patent medicine and quack cures. It was believed by medical science that small doses of radiation would cause no harm and the harmful effects of large doses were temporary.
The widespread use of radium in medicine ended when it was discovered that physical tolerance was lower than expected and exposure caused long term cell damage that could appear in carcinoma up to 40 years after treatment. The use of radiation continues today as a treatment for cancer in radiation therapy, where it is applied with strict safety precautions.
- 1 Early development of radiotherapy (1895–1905)
- 2 Further development and the use of radium (1905–1915)
- 3 Commercialization, quackery, and the end of an era (1915–1935)
- 4 Radiation therapy today (1935—)
- 5 Notes
- 6 References
Early development of radiotherapy (1895–1905)
The imaging properties of x-rays were discovered, their practical use for research and diagnostics was immediately apparent, and soon their use spread in the medical field. X-rays were used to diagnose bone fractures, heart disease, and phthisis. Inventive procedures for different diagnostic purposes were created, such as filling digestive cavities with bismuth, which allowed them to be seen through tissue and bone.
Discovery of the therapeutic potential of radiation
During early practical work and scientific investigation, experimenters noticed that prolonged exposure to x-rays created inflammation and, more rarely, tissue damage on the skin. The biological effect attracted the interest of Léopold Freund and Eduard Schiff, who, only a month or two after Röntgen's announcement, suggested they be used in the treatment of disease. At approximately the same time, Emil Grubbe, of Chicago was possibly the first American physician to use x-rays to treat cancer, beginning in 1896, began experimenting in Chicago with medical uses of x-rays. Escharotics by this time had already been used to treat skin malignancies through caustic burns, and electrotherapy had also been experimented with, in the aim to stimulate the skin tissue.
The first attempted x-ray treatment was by Victor Despeignes, a French physician who used them on a patient with stomach cancer. In 1896, he published a paper with the results: a week-long treatment was followed by a diminution of pain and reduction in the size of the tumor, though the case was ultimately fatal. The results were inconclusive, because the patient was concurrently being given other treatments. Freund's first experiment was a tragic failure; he applied x-rays to a naevus in order to induce epilation and a deep ulcer resulted, which resisted further treatment by radiation. The first successful treatment was by Schiff, working with Freund, in a case of lupus vulgaris. A year later, in 1897, the two published a report of their success and this provoked further experimentation in x-ray therapies. Thereafter they did a successful treatment of lupus erythematosus in 1898. The lesion took a common form of a 'butterfly-patch' which appeared on both sides of the face, and Schiff applied the irradiation to one side only, in order to compare the effects.
Within a few months, scientific journals were swamped with accounts of the successful treatment of different types of skin tissue malignancies with x-rays. In Sweden, Thor Stenbeck published results of the first successful treatments of rodent ulcer and epithelioma in 1899, later that year confirmed by Tage Sjögren. Soon afterwards, their findings were confirmed by a number of other physicians.
The nature of the active agent in therapeutic treatment was still unknown, and subject to wide dispute. Freund and Schiff believed it to because of electrical discharge, Nikola Tesla argued they were because of the ozone generated by the x-rays, while others argued that it was the x-rays themselves. Tesla's position was soon refuted, and only the other two theories remained. In 1900, Robert Kienböck produced a study based on a series of experiments that demonstrated that it was the x-rays themselves. Studies published in 1899 and 1900 suggested that the rays varied in penetration due to according to the degree of vacuum in the tube.
Niels Finsen and phototherapy
Niels Finsen, a Faroese-Danish physician, had by that time already pursued interest in the biological effects of light. He published a paper, Om Lysets Indvirkninger paa Huden ("On the effects of light on the skin") in 1893. Inspired by the discovery that x-rays could have therapeutic effects, he extended his research to examine directed light rays. In 1896, he published a paper on his findings, Om Anvendelse i Medicinen af koncentrerede kemiske Lysstraaler ("The use of concentrated chemical light rays in medicine"). Finsen discovered that lupus was amenable to treatment by ultraviolet rays when separated out by a system of quartz crystals, and thereafter created a lamp to sift out the rays. The so-called Finsen lamp became widely used in for phototherapy, and derivatives of it became used when experimenting with other types of radiotherapy. Modifications were made to Finsen's original design, and it found its most common forms in the Finsen-Reyn lamp and Finsen-Lomholt lamp .
From initial therapeutic experiments, a new field of x-ray therapy was born, referred to as röntgenotherapy after Wilhelm Röntgen, the discoverer of x-rays. It was still unclear how the x-rays acted on the skin; however, it was generally agreed upon that the area affected was killed and either discharged or absorbed.
By 1900, there were four well established classes of problems that were treated by x-ray, based on a set of five classes initially outlined by Freund: 1. in hypertrichosis, for the removal of unwanted hair; 2. in the treatment of disease of hair and hair follicles in which it was necessary to remove hair; 3. in the treatment of inflammatory affections on the skin like eczema and acne; 4. and in the treatment of malignant affections on the skin in cases like lupus and epithelioma.
Additionally, x-rays were successfully applied to other appearances of carcinoma, trials were done in treating leukemia, and because of the supposed bactericidal properties, there were suggestions it could be used in diseases such as tuberculosis. Experiments were also done using x-rays to treat epilepsy, which had previously also experimentally been treated with electrical currents.
Further development and the use of radium (1905–1915)
Because of the excitement over the new treatment, literature about the therapeutic effects of x-rays often exaggerated the propensity to cure different diseases. Reports of the fact that in some cases treatment worsened some of the patients' conditions were ignored in favor of hopeful optimism. Henry G. Piffard referred to these practitioners as "radiomaniacs" and "radiografters". It was found that x-rays were only capable of producing a cure in certain cases of the basal cell type of epithelioma and exceedingly unreliable in malignant cancer, not making it a suitable replacement for surgery. In many cases of treatment, the cancer recurred after a period of time. X-ray experiments in pulmonary tuberculosis proved useless. Aside from the medical profession losing faith in the ability of x-ray therapy, the public increasingly viewed it as a dangerous type of treatment. This resulted in a period of pessimism about the use of x-rays, which lasted from about 1905 to 1910 or 1912.
Soon after the discovery of radium in 1898 by Marie Curie, there was speculation in whether the radiation could be used for therapy in the same way as that from x-rays. The physiological effect of radium was first observed in 1900 by Otto Walkhoff, and later confirmed by what famously known as the "Becquerel burn". In 1901, Henri Becquerel had placed a tube of radium in a waistcoat pocket where it had remained for several hours; a week or two after which there was severe inflammation of his skin underneath where the radium had been kept. Ernest Besnier, a dermatologist, examined the skin and expressed the opinion that it was due to the radium, leading to experiments by Curie which confirmed it. Besnier suggested the use of radium for therapy along the same purposes as x-rays and ultraviolet rays.
Becquerel for this purpose loaned some radium to Henri-Alexandre Danlos of the hôpital St.Louis in Paris in 1901. Danlos successfully treated a few cases of lupus with an admixture of radium and barium chloride. Further trials of radium therapy began, though at a much slower pace than did those using x-rays because radium was expensive and difficult to obtain.
Methods of application
Radium was soon seen as a way to treat disorders that were not affected enough by x-ray treatment because it could be applied in a multitude of ways in which x-rays could not. Different methods of applying radium had been tested, which fell into two categories: the use of radium emanation (now referred to as radon), and the use of radium salts.
One method using emanation was through inhalation, where it was mixed with air. Radium inhalation had been most studied in Germany, where regular inhalation institutes were established, and the goal was to target the lungs. That was done either to treat lung diseases, like tuberculosis, or to be absorbed through the surface of the lung to the blood, where it could circulate through the body. It was claimed that the beneficial effects produced by radium water baths were the result of inhalation of the vapors.
Another method of treatment was to condense the emanation at liquid air temperature on substances such as vasoline, glycerine, and lanoline, to apply externally to the part affected; or on quinine, bismuth, subnitrate, and arsenic, to be consumed or applied internally.
Radium emanation was also passed into glass or metal tubes or flat glass-tight applicators and applied in the same way as radium tubes. In other cases was also deposited on metal points or flat surfaces of metal using electrical devices, which had the same level of radioactivity as the parent radium, but lasted a shorter duration. One way of treatment was to then drive the deposits of radioactive material into tissue using galvanic current. It was also a method of applying radium emanation to a specially designed applicator constructed to suit the needs of the patient, who could later take it home.
Dilute solutions of radium salts were also made, meant to be used internally. Patients would be prescribed regular dosages. More rarely, the salts were also suspended in liquids to be injected in subcutaneous treatments, which could be applied locally to affected tissues. That was considered the most expensive method, because the radium used was irreparably lost.
As with radium emanation, solutions of free radium salts were also placed in tubes; in this case, the tubes were made from platinum. In metal tubes, the radium could be employed in a number of ways: externally; to the interior of the body in places like the mouth, nose, esophagus, rectum and vagina; and into the substance of a tumor through incisions.
In 1903, the discoverer of the electron, J. J. Thomson, wrote a letter to the journal Nature in which he detailed his discovery of the presence of radioactivity in well water. Soon after, others found that the waters in many of the world's most famous health springs were also radioactive. This radioactivity is due to the presence of radium emanation produced by the radium that is present in the ground through which the waters flow. In 1904, Nature published a study on the natural radioactivity of different mineral waters.
Inspired by this, using preparations of radium salt in bath water was suggested as a way for patients to be treated at home, as the radio-activity in the bathwater was permanent. Radium baths became used experimentally to treat arthritis, gout, and neuralgias.
Röntgenotherapy vs. radium therapy
X-rays and radium were noted by physicians to have different advantages in different cases. The most marked effects produced with radium therapy were with lupus, ulcerous growths, and keloid, particularly because they could be applied more specifically to tissues than with x-rays. Radium was generally to be preferred when a localized reaction was desired, while for x-rays when a large area needed to be treated. Radium was also believed to be bactericidal, while x-rays were not. Because they could not be applied locally, x-rays were also found to have worse cosmetic effects than radium when treating malignancies. In certain cases, a combination of x-ray and radium therapy was suggested. In many skin diseases, the ulcers would be treated with radium and the surrounding areas with x-rays so it would positively affect the lymphatic systems.
Tuberculosis and iodo-radium therapy
After using radium in the surgicial treatment of tuberculosis, researchers including Béla Augustin and A. de Szendeffy soon developed a treatment using radioactive metholated iodine, which was patented under the name dioradin (formed from "iodine and radium") in 1911. Application of this treatment was referred to as iodo-radium therapy, and involved injecting dioradin intramuscularly. It seemed promising to the developers, because in several cases, fever and hemoptysis had disappeared. Inhalation of iodine alone had been an experimental treatment for tuberculosis in France between 1830 and 1870.
Commercialization, quackery, and the end of an era (1915–1935)
Widespread commercial exploitation of radium only began in 1913, by which time more efficient methods of extracting radium from pitchblende had been discovered and the mining of radium had taken off.
Radium had commonly been put into bath salts, waters, and muds was in low-grade preparations, due to the expense, and their usefulness in curative solutions was questioned, since it had been agreed upon by physicians that radium could only be used successfully in high doses. It was believed that even radiation emanation at higher doses that were useful would cause no harm, because the radioactive deposits were found to have been absorbed and released in urine and waste within a period of three hours.
Radiation emanation activators
Radium emanation activators, apparatuses that would apply radium emanation to water, started being produced and marketed. Scientifically constructed emanators were sold to hospitals, universities, and independent researchers. Certain companies advertised that they would only give them out to others on a medical prescription and would guarantee the strength of radium in each dose.
Many products which imitated emanation activators were more broadly marketed to the public. One such product was the Revigator, a "radioactive water crock." A dispensing jar made of radium-containing ore, the idea was that radon produced by the ore would dissolve in the water overnight. It was advertised: "Fill jar every night. Drink freely . . . when thirsty and upon arising and retiring, average six or more glasses daily." The American Medical Association (AMA) was concerned that the public was being fleeced by charlatans. In response, the AMA established guidelines (in effect from 1916 to 1929) that emanators seeking AMA approval had to generate more than 2 μCi (74 kBq) of radon per liter of water in a 24-hour period. Most devices on the market, including the Revigator did not meet that standard.
Many other quack cures and patent medicines were sold on the market. Radithor, a solution of radium salts, which was claimed by its developer William J. A. Bailey to have curative properties. Many brands of toothpaste were laced with radium that was claimed to make teeth shine whiter, such as Doramad Radioactive Toothpaste. Ostensibly, this would be because the radium would kill the bacteria in a person's mouth. One item, called "Degnen's Radio-Active Eye Applicator" manufactured by the Radium Appliance Company of Los Angeles, California, was sold as a treatment for myopia, hypermetropia, presbyopia and heterophobia. Face creams and powders were sold, with names like 'Revigorette' and 'Tho-radia'. It was also sold as a supplement to smoking cigarettes. Companies also marked radioactive pads and compresses for the treatment of illnesses.
Joachimsthal radium spa hotel
In light of the supposed curative properties of radioactivity, a spa was opened up in Joachimsthal, the place at which Madame Curie gathered some of her original samples of radium from spring waters. Radon inhalation rooms were set up, where air tubes carried the gas up from a processing tank in the basement; the visitor would then use it through an inhalation apparatus. Baths were set up which were also irradiated, and irradiated air was also filtered through a trumpet-like pipe for inhalation.
Public health concerns
Concerns about radium were brought up before the United States Senate by California Senator John D. Works as early as 1915. In a floor speech he quoted letters from doctors asking about the efficacy of the products that were marketed. He stressed that radiation had the effect of making many cancers worse, many doctors thought the belief that radium could be used to cure cancers at that stage of the development of therapy was a "delusion" — one doctor quoted cited a failure-to-success rate of 100 to 1 — and the effects of radium water were undemonstrated.
Around the start of the 1920s, new public health concerns were sparked by the deaths of factory workers at a radioluminsecent watch factory, later referred to as the Radium Girls. In 1932, a well-known industrialist, Eben Byers died of radiation poisoning from the use of Radithor, a radium water guaranteed by the manufacturer to contain 2 μCi of radium. Cases sprung up of the development of carcinoma in patients who had used conventional radium therapy up to 40 years after the original treatments.
Robley D. Evans made the first measurements of exhaled radon and radium excretion from a former dial painter in 1933. At MIT he gathered dependable body content measurements from 27 dial painters. This information was used in 1941 by the National Bureau of Standards to establish the tolerance level for radium of 0.1 μCi (3.7 kBq).
At the International Congress of Oncology in Paris in 1922, Henri Coutard, a French radiologist working with the Institut Curie, presented evidence that laryngeal cancer could be treated without disastrous side-effects. Coutard was inspired by the observations of Claudius Regaud, who found that a single dose of x-rays sufficient enough to produce severe skin damage and tissue destruction in a rabbit, if administered in fractions, over a course of days, would sterilize the rabbit but have no effect on subcutaneous tissues.
By 1934, Coutard had developed a protracted, fractionated process that remains the basis for current radiation therapy. Coutard's dosage and fractionation were designed to create a severe but recoverable acute mucosal reaction. Unlike previous physicians, who believed that cancerous cells were more affected by radiation, he assumed that the population of cancerous cells had the same sensitivity for regeneration as normal cells. Coutard reported a 23% cure rate in the treatment of head and neck cancer. In 1935, hospitals everywhere began following his treatment plan.
Radiation therapy today (1935—)
Treatments of cancer by x-ray today generally follows Coutard's fractionated process, while radiated rods are used in brachytherapy.
The three main divisions of radiation therapy are external beam radiation therapy or teletherapy, brachytherapy or sealed source radiation therapy, and systemic radioisotope therapy or unsealed source radiotherapy. The differences relate to the position of the radiation source; external is outside the body, brachytherapy uses sealed radioactive sources placed precisely in the area under treatment, and systemic radioisotopes are given by infusion or oral ingestion. Brachytherapy can use temporary or permanent placement of radioactive sources. The temporary sources are usually placed by a technique called afterloading. In afterloading a hollow tube or applicator is placed surgically in the organ to be treated, and the sources are loaded into the applicator after the applicator is implanted. This minimizes radiation exposure to health care personnel. Particle therapy is a special case of external beam radiation therapy where the particles are protons or heavier ions. Intraoperative radiation therapy or IORT is a special type of radiation therapy that is delivered immediately after surgical removal of the cancer. This method has been employed in breast cancer (TARGeted Introperative radiation therapy or TARGIT), brain tumors and rectal cancers.
Radioactive iodine, as developed in 1911, survives today primarily in the treatment of thyrotoxicosis (hyperthyroidism) and some types of thyroid cancer that absorb iodine. Treatment involves the important iodine isotope iodine-131 (131I), often simply called "radioiodine" (though technically all radioisotopes of iodine are radioiodines; see isotopes of iodine).
- Pusey 1900, p. 302
- Kassabian 1907, p. 501
- Coe 1912, p. 302
- Singer 1914, p. xxv
- Mould 1993
- Squibb 1900, p. 722
- MacKee 1921, p. 19
- Pioneer in X-Ray Therapy
- Belot 1905, p. 364
- Freund 1904, p. 299
- Belot 1905, p. 812
- Williams 1902, p. 438
- Belot 1905, p. 367
- Belot 1905, p. 88
- Metzenbaum 1905, p. 22
- Sinclair 1905, p. 1103
- Grubbe 1902, p. 692
- Pusey 1900, p. 303
- Belot 1905, pp. 261–302
- Kassabian 1907, p. 488
- MacKee 1921, p. 20
- Metzenbaum 1905, pp. 26–27
- Cameron 1912, p. 171
- MacKee 1921, p. 25
- Knox 1918, p. 500
- Knox 1918, p. 499
- Knox 1918, p. 498
- Cameron 1912, p. 173
- Knox 1918, p. 501
- Strutt 1904, p. 473
- Tousey 1915, p. 1115
- Cameron 1912, p. 174
- Boggs 1919, p. 77
- Simpson 1917, p. 1
- Science Museum London
- Callé 1922, p. 55
- Bright 1910, p. 558
- Moore & Kithil 1913, p. 79
- Moore & Kithil 1913, p. 8
- Moore & Kithil 1913, p. 110
- Frame 1989
- Oak Ridge 1998
- Works 1915, pp. 107–108
- Chamberlain & Young 1937
- Halperin, Perez & Brady 2008, p. 4
- Bomford, Kunkler & Walter 2003, p. 316
- Beyzadeoglu, Özyigit & Ebruli 2010, p. xxiii
- Pusey, Wm. Allen (1900). "Roentgen rays in the treatment of skin diseases and for the removal of hair". Journal of cutaneous diseases including syphilis (William & Wood) 18: 302–318.
- Squibb, E. H. (1900). "Brief comments on the Materia Medica and therapeutics of the year ending October 1, 1899 – Roentgen rays". Transactions of the New York State Medical Association for the year 1884–1899 (New York State Medical Association) 16: 710–731.
- Freund, Leopold (1904). Elements of general radio-therapy for practitioners. Rebman.
- Belot, Joseph (1905). Radiotherapy in skin disease. Rebman.
- Grubbe, Emile H. (1902). "X-rays in the treatment of cancer and other malignant diseases". Medical record (W. Wood) 62: 692–695.
- Jones, Philip Mills (1900). "Treatment of lupus by x-rays". Philadelphia medical journal (Philadelphia Medical Pub. Co) 5: 63–64.
- Williams, Francis Henry (1902). Roentgen rays in medicine and surgery. Macmillan.
- Gould, George Milbry; Lloyd, James Hendrie (1898). "X-Ray Burns.—Amputation of the Thigh, X-Ray Burns; Their Nature and Treatment". The Philadelphia medical journal (Philadelphia Medical Pub. Co) 1: 354.
- Knox, Robert (1918). Radiography and Radio-therapeutics: Radio-therapeutics. Macmillan.
- Tousey, Sinclair (1915). Medical electricity Röntgen rays and radium: with a practical chapter on phototherapy. Saunders.
- Kassabian, Mihran Krikor (1907). Röntgen rays and electro-therapeutics: with chapters on radium and phototherapy. J.B. Lippincott Company.
- MacKee, George Miller (1921). X-rays and radium in the treatment of diseases of the skin. Lea & Febiger.
- Cameron, Alexander Thomas (1912). Radium and radioactivity. Society for promoting Christian knowledge.
- Metzenbaum, Myron (1905). "Radium: Its value in the treatment of lupus, rodent ulcer, and epithelioma, with reports of cases". International clinics (J.B. Lippincott) 4:14: 21–31.
- Coe, Henry Waldo (1912). "New Research on the Idio-Radium Therapy in Tuberculose". Medical sentinel 20: 302–303.
- Bernheim, Samuel (1911). Radiumtherapy in Tuberculosis and Dioradin (Radio-active Mentholated Iodine) As Used in the Treatment of Tuberculosis. Vail-Ballou Co.
- Bright, Conrad Frederick I. (1910). "A British radium discovery". The Journal of industrial and engineering chemistry (American Chemical Society) 2: 558.
- Moore, Richard Bishop; Kithil, Karl Ludwig (1913). "A British radium discovery". A preliminary report on uranium, radium, and vanadium (Govt. print. off.). 70–74.
- Strutt, J.R. (1904). "A study of the radio-activity of certain minerals and mineral waters". Nature 69: 473–475. doi:10.1038/069473b0.
- Singer, Heinrich (1914). "Radiation Emanation". Maryland Medical Journal 57:7: xxiv–xxv.
- Viol, Charles Herman; Cameron, William Heron (1915). Radium (Pittsburgh, PA) 4–6 http://books.google.com/books?id=xgYhAQAAIAAJ. Missing or empty
- Simpson, Frank E. (1917). "Radium Therapy". The Radium Quarterly (The Radium Institute) 1:1.
- New, Gordon B. (1917). "Radium in the Treatment of Lymphangioma of the Tongue". The Radium Quarterly (The Radium Institute) 1:1.
- Simpson, Frank E. (1917). "Radium Therapy with Special Reference to the Use of Radium in Dermatology". The Radium Quarterly (The Radium Institute) 1:2.
- Simpson, Frank Edward (1922). Radium Therapy. C.V. Mosby Company.
- Callé, Augustus (1922). Post-graduate medicine: prevention and treatment of disease. Appleton.
- Mould, Richard Francis (1993). A century of x-rays and radioactivity in medicine: with emphasis on photographic records of the early years. CRC Press.
- Frame, Paul (November 5, 1989). "Radioactive curative devices and spas". Oak Ridger.
- Oak Ridge (1998-05-28). "Radioactive Quack Cures".
- Works, John D. (1915). "Status of Radium". The public health service ... speech ... in the Senate of the United States, January 5 and 6, 1915 (Govt. print. off.): 105–109.
- Boggs, R.H. (1910). "The comparative value of radium and Roentgen radiation". Minnesota medicine (Minnesota Medical Association): 77–78.
- Halperin, Eduard C.; Perez, Carlos A.; Brady, Luther W. (2008). Perez and Brady's principles and practice of radiation oncology. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
- Chamberlain, Edward; Young, Barton (1937). "Should the Method of Coutard be Applied in All Cases of Cancer Treated by Roentgen Rays?". Radiology.
- Bomford, C.K.; Kunkler, I.H.; Walter, Joseph (2003). Walter and Miller's textbook of radiotherapy: radiation physics, therapy, and oncology. Elsevier Health Sciences.
- Beyzadeoglu, M.; Özyigit, Gokhan; Ebruli, Cuneyt (2010). Basic radiation and oncology. Springer.
- Coutard, Henri (October 1937). "The Results and Methods of Treatment of Cancer by Radiation". Annals of Surgery (Paris,France: Springer) 106 (4): 584–98. PMC 1390613. PMID 17857061. doi:10.1097/00000658-193710000-00010.
- Science Museum London. "Iodine treatment apparatus for tuberculosis, France,1830–1870".
- "Pioneer in X-Ray Therapy". Science (New Series) 125 (3236): 18–19. 4 January 1957. doi:10.1126/science.125.3236.18. (jstor stable link)